Leigh Occhi - Part 2
In Part 2 of Leigh Occhi's story, we dig into Oscar "Mike" Kearns — the church Sunday school teacher whose own crime, committed nine months after Leigh vanished, shares chilling parallels with her case — and the 2025 search that may finally bring answers.
Leigh Occhi - Part 1
On the morning of August 27, 1992, 13-year-old Leigh Occhi was home alone in Tupelo, Mississippi. Less than an hour later, her mother returned to find blood on the walls and her daughter gone. Thirty-four years later, there's still no arrest — but there are names that have never been ruled out.
Anthonette Cayedito
In the early hours of April 6, 1986, someone knocked on the door of a home in Gallup, New Mexico. Nine-year-old Anthonette Cayedito answered it. She has never been seen again. A year later, a terrified girl called police and gave her name — before the line went dead.
Susan Walsh
On July 16, 1996, journalist and former exotic dancer Susan Walsh told her estranged husband she'd be back in half an hour. She was never seen again. What followed was a case involving the Russian mob, an underground vampire subculture, a missing calendar page, and a mystery that remains unsolved 30 years later.
Mikelle Biggs
On January 2, 1999, 11-year-old Mikelle Biggs was waiting outside her Mesa, Arizona home for an ice cream truck. Her sister went inside to grab her coat. When she came back — less than two minutes later — Mikelle was gone. Her bicycle was lying in the road, one wheel still spinning.
Karlie Gusé
On the morning of October 13, 2018, 16-year-old Karlie Gusé walked out of her family's home in Chalfant Valley, California — without her phone, without her wallet, and without a coat. She hasn't been seen since.
Norine Higuchi Brown
On the night of December 12, 1990, 31-year-old Norine Higuchi Brown left her New Hyde Park, New York home to pick up ingredients for Christmas cookies. Her car was found the next morning in the supermarket parking lot — locked, with Christmas presents in the back. Norine was nowhere to be found.
Joe Pichler
Former child actor Joe Pichler had big plans for his future—but after an emotional late-night phone call on January 5, 2006, he vanished from Bremerton, Washington. Days later, his car was found parked behind a local business with his phone inside, but Joe was nowhere to be found. In this episode of And Then They Were Gone, we break down what’s confirmed, what’s disputed, and why his family believes the official narrative doesn’t explain what happened.
Debbie Sassen
Eight-year-old Debbie Sassen vanished on February 13, 1996—during what should have been a routine, 10-minute walk home from school in Düsseldorf. There was no confirmed witness to an abduction, no recovered clothing or bag, and no trace of where she went next. Nearly 30 years later, new investigative movement has pushed this case back into the spotlight. In this episode of And Then They Were Gone, we break down the timeline, the long-running theories, and the recent developments that could finally lead to answers.
Andre Bryant
On March 29, 1989, 22-year-old Monique Rivera left her Brooklyn apartment with her six-week-old son, Andre Terrance Bryant, after two women urged her to join them for a day out. She never returned. Within 24 hours, Monique was found murdered in the Bronx—and baby Andre was gone. In this episode of And Then They Were Gone, we break down the timeline, the unsettling details, and the leads that still haunt Andre’s disappearance decades later.
The Disappearance of Leyla Mastova McCullagh
In 2012, Leesburg mother Leyla Mastova McCullagh vanished without a trace after a disturbing domestic history. Foul play is suspected — but her case remains unsolved.
The Disappearance of Sebastian Rogers: A Troubling Case with Few Leads
Sebastian Rogers, a 15-year-old from Hendersonville, Tennessee, disappeared on February 26, 2024. Despite extensive searches, no trace of the missing teen has been found. Diagnosed with autism and a rare genetic condition, his case has gained national attention. Learn about the circumstances of his disappearance and the ongoing search efforts in this podcast episode.
The Disappearance of Sky Metalwala: A Washington Mystery
Sky Metalwala, a two-year-old from Bellevue, Washington, vanished on November 6, 2011, sparking a mystery that remains unsolved. Despite investigations and public interest, no concrete evidence has surfaced. His mother, Julia Biryukova, refuses to cooperate with police, leaving many unanswered questions. Learn about the ongoing case and theories surrounding his disappearance.
The Disappearance of Kadin black: A Teen’s Struggle
The disappearance of 19-year-old Kadin McKallaster Black in December 2022 from Wrightsville, Pennsylvania, remains a mystery. Struggling with mental health issues and legal troubles, Kadin vanished without a trace, leaving his family searching for answers. His case remains unsolved, and authorities urge anyone with information to come forward. Listen to our two-part podcast episode on his case.
The Disappearance of Brianna Maitland: Part 2
In this episode, we delve into the chilling case of Brianna Maitland, who vanished 20 years ago in Vermont. Following an anonymous tip, police raided a farmhouse on Reservoir Road, uncovering drugs and weapons but no sign of Brianna. Connected to two drug dealers, Ramon Ryans and Nathaniel Jackson, Brianna's disappearance intersects with the dark underworld of drugs and crime. The investigation led to further twists, including the brutal murder of Ligia Rae Collins by Ellen Ducharme, sparking fears of a grim link to Brianna’s fate. Despite numerous leads and ongoing efforts by her family and private investigators, Brianna's case remains a haunting mystery, with authorities and loved ones still seeking answers and justice.
20 Years Gone: The story of Brianna Maitland - part 1
Brianna Maitland's disappearance in Montgomery, Vermont, continues to baffle investigators and captivate the public's attention. Despite extensive search efforts and numerous leads, the mystery surrounding Brianna's vanishing remains unresolved. Join us for part one of a two-part podcast series discussing Brianna Maitland’s disappearance.
Unraveling the Cory Bigsby Case: A Story of Tragedy and Justice
Explore the intricate details of the Cory Bigsby case, a gripping tale of tragedy and justice unfolding in the courtroom, on this week’s episode of ‘And Then They Were Gone.’
The Mysterious Disappearance of Anna Christian Waters: A 50-Year Search for Answers
In Anna Christian Waters' puzzling story, her family's troubles and strange connections cast a shadow over her life. Born into a complicated situation, Anna faced uncertainties due to her father George and his friend George Brody. Their odd behavior left lingering questions, especially when Anna vanished in 1973. Despite many years passing, the search for answers hasn't stopped. Anna's family holds onto hope, determined to find out what happened to her.
The Disappearance of Gretchen Fleming: A Deep Dive
Gretchen Eve Fleming's disappearance on December 3, 2022, sent shockwaves through Parkersburg, West Virginia, leaving her family and community grappling with unanswered questions. Last seen with Preston Pierce, a man with a troubling past, Gretchen's story unveils a web of suspicion and uncertainty. Despite exhaustive search efforts and forensic testing, the truth behind Gretchen's vanishing act remains elusive. As the investigation continues, her family and the tight-knit community remain united in their quest for justice and closure, determined to unravel the mysteries surrounding Gretchen's fate.